There is one word used to describe people who think that they can get juicy meat using only a grill and that word is “amateurs.” In order to achieve that ultimate meat flavor, you’ll need to use a smoker. So, if you’re willing to get into smoking but don’t want to spend too much time sitting around and tending a fire, then a propane smoker is probably the right choice for you.
Propane smokers are convenient, easy to use, and a great choice for beginners since they feature the “set it and forget it” option. Majority of propane smokers feature a simple design which makes them compact yet provides plenty of cooking space.
Plus, they offer great value for the money. Propane smokers are a great choice since they let you cook food at a consistent temperature so you could achieve that tender, mouthwatering taste. In addition, all gas-powered smokers heat up much faster than the electric or charcoal ones. So, what is the best propane smoker you can buy? We’ve done all the hard work and came up with this list that will hopefully help you decide which propane smoker is the right one for your needs.
How to Pick the Right Propane Smoker?
If you’re planning to invest money in a propane smoker so you could cook for your family, friends, or for a large group of people, you need to make sure that your smoker is perfectly cut out for the job. If you’re reading our review, the chances are that you are not a pit-master and that you don’t know what features should you look for in a smoker. And, even though you might have heard about some popular propane smokers, it is likely that you still don’t have a complete picture of the features a propane smoker should have. Lucky for you, we’ve covered all the points you should take into consideration when buying your first propane smoker so that all your meals taste amazing.
One of the first things you should take into consideration when buying a propane smoker is the cooking surface. In order to pick a smoker with an effective cooking surface, you need to think about the number of people you plan to cook for. Then, you can decide how big the cooking surface should be. One good thing about propane smokers is that you can use racks to the interior surface to augment it and adjust it to your needs.
Besides the size of the cooking surface, the size of the smoker matters as well. First-time buyers need to think about moving and storing their smoker. For example, if you travel often and want to take your smoker with you every now and then, you should get a unit that is easily transportable thanks to its detachable legs and collapsible spacing.
Did you know that you can buy a smoker that can be used for something else besides smoking? For example, you can get a grill smoker combination that features both smoking sections and cooking surfaces. Such units make it easier to smoke meats but also cook a wide variety of other foods as well.
Once you invest money in a quality propane smoker, you’ll want it to last as long as possible. And one way to extend the lifetime of a smoker is by cleaning and maintaining it regularly. To make your life easier, you should look for smokers that can be cleaned with little effort. For example, some smokers come with a detachable ash pan that makes the cleaning process incredibly easy.
Even if you buy the best propane smoker there is, you might need to replace one or more of its parts. Regardless of how carefully you use your smoker, accidents are prone to happen. That is the reason why you should research how easy it is to buy parts for a smoker before actually buying one.
After reading all of these points, it should be easier for you to realize what the right smoker for your needs is. To make choosing a propane smoker even easier, take a look at our list of the best propane smokers currently available on the market.
Top Pick -Smoke Hollow 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker
Smoke Hollow 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker Overview
Perhaps the biggest limitation of propane smokers is the range of temperatures they can hit. With this Smoke Hollow smoker, you will never have to worry about temperatures. The unit comes with two burners that can maintain a steady temperature.
According to the manufacturer, if you shut off one burner the unit will maintain the temperature of about 125°F on the top rack which is perfect for smoking cheese. In addition, the unit sports a built-in thermostat and thermometer which gauges the temperature at which it’s set in real-time. And the greatest thing about the thermometer is that it is very accurate. The thermostat dial is a bit delicate, but it sets consistent temperatures.
Smoke Hollow 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker Features
Dual Burners for Temperature Maintenance
As already mentioned, this propane smoker grill comes with dual gas burners that give you advanced control of the temperature inside the unit. If you need a high temperature, simply leave both burners lit. However, if you want to maintain a low heat, leave only one burner on. The dual burners actually give you more precision and control when adjusting the temperature of the smoker. And, the best part is that you won’t have to leave the burners on full blast to maintain temperature thanks to the quality steel construction that keeps the heat inside of the cooking chamber.
Two Flavoring Pans
Wanting to create a smoker that will stand out from the others, the manufacturer added two flavoring pans to this propane smoker. This allows the user to fill two pans with wood chips and burn them one at a time. This will ensure that the smoker doesn’t run out of flavoring and also give the user more time between refills. When full, each pan can last for about three hours meaning that you can leave this propane smoker unattended for up to six hours.
Dual Door System
Constantly opening and closing a cooking chamber to replace wood chips might have a negative impact and cause your meat to come out dry and flavorless. This Smoke Hollow propane smoker deals with this issue by incorporating a dual door access system. Whenever you need to refill the wood chips, you simply open a separate door located on the bottom of the unit. By doing so, you won’t lose any heat or smoke and your food will come out perfect.
Considering that the Smoke Hollow 44-inch propane smoker is a large unit, many buyers believe that it is hard to assemble. However, the assembly is quite easy and can be completed within an hour. The only downside is that you might need someone to help you out with the heavier parts of the smoker.
Ease of Use
Smoke Hollow is one of those propane smokers that make smoking your food incredibly easy. Instead of having to fuss with charcoal and pellets, all you’ll have to do is make sure that you have gas in your tank. Also, place some wood chips in the wood box and the smoker will do all the rest for you.
Smoke Hollow 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker Pros
- Features a durable and sturdy build.
- Has a huge cooking area.
- The smoker is very easy to use.
- Assembling the unit is fairly simple.
- The smoker is capable of maintaining a steady temperature.
- The food is cooked evenly.
Smoke Hollow 44-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker CONs
- Great for cooking large pieces of meat, but not smaller pieces.
- The unit is bulky and heavy, making it hard to move it around.
- A small amount of smoke might leak out since the sealing of the door is not very good.
Runner Up –Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker
Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker Overview
You’ve enjoyed the benefits of thermostat control with your home, car, and oven. Now, you’ll enjoy those same benefits with your ThermoTemp XL Propane Smoker from Masterbuilt. Simply turn the dial and this smoker does the rest. Our patent-pending technology adjusts the flame to maintain consistent temperature, for delicious results every time.
The Masterbuilt ThermoTemp makes propane smoking simple and safe. No more monitoring or adjusting temperature. Patent-pending innovation lets you set the temperature and walk away. The safety shut-off valve provides a safe smoking experience while the four smoking racks provide plenty of room to smoke your favorite foods. Share the goodness of slow-smoked food with Masterbuilt.
Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker Features
This propane tank smoker comes with an automatic shut-off valve that guarantees a safe smoking experience. This safety feature is very useful in the case that the flame blows out. In addition, a fuel gauge allows the user to know exactly how much fuel is left in the tank.
Similarly to the top pick, this Masterbuilt propane smoker features a dual-door design that allows the user to add wood chips without losing any heat. In addition, the unit comes with a built-in thermostat. Thanks to the advanced technology behind it, the flame adjustment is automatic and the smoker can maintain a consistent temperature for hours.
Incredible Food Capacity
Considering the affordable price of this propane smoker, the food capacity is quite impressive. You can use it to cook whole chickens and turkeys, ribs, pork butts, sausages, and burgers. The unit is perfect for family gatherings or even parties with friends.
Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker PROs
- Very easy to use.
- Comes with the new ThermoTemp feature.
- The unit provides outstanding temperature control.
- Provides great flavor.
- The smoker comes with advanced safety features.
Masterbuilt 20050716 Thermotemp Propane Smoker Cons
- The unit is smaller than expected.
- Larger items, such as turkey, can hardly fit inside the smoker.
Best Propane Smoker Under $200 – Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical LP Gas Smoker
Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical LP Gas Smoker Overview
Pit Boss vertical LP gas smokers are one of a kind. It has dual valve burner system. Both valves are controlled by a single control knob & allow for temperature control of 100 – 350 Degrees. Push-button piezo ignition makes for quick & easy lighting. This vertical smoker offers four porcelain coated cooking racks and smoking space. Large high temp glass viewing window & fully sealed high temp door seal. Its time to take your backyard smoking experience to the next level.
Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical LP Gas Smoker Features
This gas smoker is built out of quality materials and comes with three porcelain-coated cooking grids. The cooking area measures 676 square inches, making this smoker suitable for smoking a large amount of food. In addition, you won’t have to worry about impacting the smoking process when refueling the unit. Thanks to the wood-chip burner tray that is separate from the smoker, you can refill the chips and smoke your food for days.
Temperature and Control
The temperature range of this smoker is between 100-350°F and the dual burners ensure an even smoking process. The burners have a total BTU of 13,500. The unit can maintain a consistent temperature and control the amount of smoke entering the chamber.
The user can control the temperature of both valves by using a single control knob. Lighting the valves is also very simple. The only thing you’ll have to do is press the ignition button.
Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical LP Gas Smoker PROs
- The unit can be bought at a reasonable price.
- The smoker features a dual burner, easy control knob, and a separate fuel chamber.
- The unit features a door with a large window.
- This smoker is covered by the manufacturer’s warranty.
Pit Boss Grills 77435 Vertical LP Gas Smoker CONs
- The user has to assemble the unit on his own
Honorable Mention-Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker
Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker Overview
Start a new trend for the family barbecue with the 38202G Smoke Hollow Gas Smoker. It has a two door system that allows the user to feed the water and wood pans without having to open the top door and releasing heat and smoke.
The upper and lower vent controls on the vertical gas smoker make it easier to manage internal heat and moisture. It also features a cast brass, gas control system that gives the user ultimate control and increases the low to high temperature range.
Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker Features
Smoking Made Easy
If you ever wondered how to use a propane smoker, let us explain this simple process to you. Similarly to other Smoke Hollow units, in order to get this unit running, you simply need to start the unit on high and load the meat when you’re ready. The gas provides a steady temperature, so you can leave your food inside without worrying about temperature fluctuations. Using a propane smoker guarantees that your food will never come out over- or underdone.
Quality and Assembly
Buying this propane smoker means buying a high-quality unit that will last for many years to come. Since the smoker is made out of steel, you don’t have to worry about it breaking down easily. However, in order to start using your Smoke Hollow 38-inch smoker, you will need to put it together on your own. Majority of buyers claim that the assembly took them less than an hour.
Withstands Weather Conditions
This Smoke Hollow propane smoker was built to last and to withstand almost all weather conditions. The steel construction can withstand rain and snow. And, in order to prevent the flame from being put out, it is advised to face the unit towards the wind. However, the unit might go out when it is very windy.
Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker PROs
- Easy to use and assemble.
- Reaches the desired temperature quickly.
- Provides large cooking space.
Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker CONs
- The unit can go out when it is very windy.
Honorable Mention – Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker Overview
If you’ve been wanting to smoke your own foods, the Cuisinart 36 inch Propane Smoker is an ideal choice for any barbecue chef. The compact footprint makes it a perfect size for patios and barbecue kitchens. It’s easy to set up and includes a 40 inch hose and regulator that attaches quickly to a standard propane tank. This amazing smoker can cook all kinds of food including vegetables, beef, pork, chicken, ribs, seafood, fish, large cuts of meat, and whole birds.
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker Features
One great thing about this propane smoker is its compact size. It is perfect for smaller patios or backyards. But, don’t let the size fool you since the Cuisinart COS-244 boasts of 5.45 square feet of interior cooking space which is more than enough for cooking a variety of meats and other foods.
This Cuisinart smoker is made out of high-quality steel which makes it very durable and able to save the heat inside properly. The smoker can reach up to 450°F and maintain a steady temperature. The only downside to the sturdy build is that it makes the smoker a bit heavy.
Temperature Gauge and Wood Chip Tray
This propane tank smoker comes with a built-in temperature gauge. Unfortunately, the gauge isn’t very accurate. So, if you do need accurate readings then you should consider buying an additional thermometer.
The unit also comes with a wood chip tray. The tray is relatively small and needs constant refilling. The good thing is that refilling can be done easily without opening the main compartment, only the bottom one.
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker PROs
- The unit is sturdy.
- The smoker can reach high temperatures.
- Using this smoker is very easy.
- Refilling the trays is a convenient task.
Cuisinart COS-244 Vertical 36″ Propane Smoker CONs
- The smoker is heavy and difficult to relocate.
- Water and wood chip tray need to be refilled frequently.
Honorable Mention –Masterbuilt 20051311 GS30D 2-Door Propane Smoker
Masterbuilt 20051311 GS30D 2-Door Propane Smoker Overview
The rich, full flavor of slow-cooked food has been a staple of outdoor cookouts. The Masterbuilt 30-inch vertical gas smoker delivers smokehouse flavor as easy as grilling! The built-in temperature gauge allows you to always know the temperature of the inside of the smoker and when it’s ideal to add certain foods. The smoker has a stainless steel burner and type 1 regulator with hose.
The air damper allows better smoke control allowing you to have as much or as little smoky flavor you would like for your foods. Whether you’re cooking pork, chicken, beef or seafood, the delightfully smoky aroma that permeates from the Masterbuilt 30-inch vertical gas smoker has a way of making friends and family flock around the smoker in the spirit of good times and good food.
Masterbuilt 20051311 GS30D 2-Door Propane Smoker Features
The Masterbuilt GS30D is made out of high-quality durable materials. The unit is robust and has a solid feel to it and the unit is very likely to last for a long time. The only downside to the robust build is the weight of the unit. It is not easy to move around unless you add casters.
Two-Door Vertical Design
The vertical design of propane smokers allows more effective smoking since the smoke rises from the bottom to the top of the unit. Another advantage of a vertical design is that it doesn’t take up much space.
This smoker also features dual doors that lock in easily and keep the temperature consistent at all times. The lower door allows the user to refill the chip tray and water pan without disturbing the smoking process.
Similarly to other propane smokers, the assembly of the unit is required. However, the process is simple and straightforward. The main compartment comes preassembled and all you’ll have to do is add the legs and handles. The directions are easy to follow and your unit will be ready for use in about an hour.
Masterbuilt 20051311 GS30D 2-Door Propane Smoker PROs
- Affordable price.
- Sturdy build and large cooking space.
- Easy and straightforward assembly.
Masterbuilt 20051311 GS30D 2-Door Propane Smoker CONs
- The smoker doesn’t come with a warranty.
Honorable Mention -Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker
Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker Overview
The Char-Broil vertical propane smoker is a great way to smoke any food of your choice with a large smoking chamber, multiple rack locations, and a double drawer design. The double drawer allows for quick, easy access to tend water and wood without heat loss in the actual cooking chamber.
The propane smoker uses a simple propane burner to heat wood chips and water for smoking. The burner itself has a temperature control while your cooking chamber is monitored by a separate temperature gauge. There is also a convenient grate on the top for warming sauces or marinades in preparation of your food.
Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker Features
Distinguished Wood Chip and Water Pan Design
Unlike other propane smokers, this one comes with a wood chip and water pan that feature a unique design. You can put wood chips and water together or separately. The tray slides nicely inside the cooker, just above the heating element.
Adjustable Steel Damper and Top Grate
In order to provide better control of the smoker’s temperature, the unit comes with a damper located on top of it. The damper can be opened to make the grill burn hotter, or closed to cool the grill down. In addition, this smoker comes with a top grate that can be used to warm up sauces or marinades.
Large cooking area
This propane smoker grill features 595 square inches of cooking surface and 7,566 cubic inches of cooking space. The inside of the unit is divided by three cooking grates that allow you to smoke different types of foods at the same time.
Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker Features PROs
- The smoker is a great value for the money.
- It features economical gas consumption.
- The unit is spacious and easy to use.
- The temperature and the amount of smoke are controlled independently.
Char-Broil Vertical Liquid Propane Gas Smoker Features CONs
- Despite its capacity, the smoker comes only with three racks.
- The assembly is time-consuming.